In Louisville, Kentucky’s Cherokee Triangle neighborhood, stormwater runoff is part of a larger water quality challenge. The area was identified as a priority within the Middle Fork Beargrass Creek watershed because of the amount of pollutants carried by stormwater runoff, the prevalence of hard surfaces that limit infiltration, and aging drainage infrastructure.

The Middle Fork Beargrass Creek Watershed-based Plan identified several ways green infrastructure could help improve watershed health, from rain gardens and bioswales to permeable pavement and expanded tree canopy. For Cherokee Triangle, one of the strategies selected for further study was stormwater tree boxes: planted areas along the street that receive runoff through an opening in the curb, temporarily hold and filter that water through engineered soil, and help reduce the pollutants moving into the drainage system.

Louisville Metropolitan Sewer District (MSD), which oversees this stormwater effort, secured funding through a 319(h) Nonpoint Source Implementation Grant to support up to 15 tree box installations in coordination with ongoing catch basin rehabilitation. Catch basins are the inlets that collect runoff from streets and direct it into the drainage system. Pairing rehabilitation of that existing infrastructure with green infrastructure creates an opportunity to capture and treat some runoff before it continues through the system.

However, before moving into design and construction, MSD needed to determine where tree boxes could help and where they could realistically be installed and function as intended. Clark Dietz was brought in to evaluate that feasibility across Cherokee Triangle, balancing opportunities to capture and treat stormwater with the physical constraints of an established neighborhood.

Many homes in Cherokee Triangle have stood for more than a century, and mature trees are part of the neighborhood’s character. Potential locations had to fit within a streetscape already occupied by sidewalks, utilities, existing trees, and adjoining private property, while still receiving enough runoff to make the installation effective. Understanding those conditions became the foundation of the feasibility study.

Why Cherokee Triangle?

Cherokee Triangle is an established Louisville neighborhood within the Middle Fork Beargrass Creek watershed, approximately two miles from downtown. The roughly 90-acre study area is predominantly residential, with many homes more than a century old, along with apartments, institutional properties, more than 20,000 feet of local streets, sidewalks, and an established tree canopy.

That mix of development shapes how stormwater moves through the neighborhood. Streets, rooftops, sidewalks, and other hard surfaces leave less space for rain to soak into the ground, increasing the runoff that the drainage system must manage.

At the same time, Cherokee Triangle is not a blank slate. Much of the available space along its streets is already occupied by mature trees, sidewalks, utilities, and adjoining private property. That meant green infrastructure could not simply be placed wherever runoff was present.

For the feasibility study, the opportunity was to find locations where stormwater could be intercepted close to where it is generated while still fitting into the surrounding neighborhood. Doing so could also help address one of the water quality concerns associated with urban runoff: urban nonpoint source pollution.

Complex Concepts Understood: Urban Nonpoint Source Pollution

Urban nonpoint source (NPS) pollution comes from materials spread across streets, properties, and other surfaces rather than from a single discharge point. It can include sediment, oils, automotive fluids, bacteria, nutrients, salts, and other contaminants.

Between storms, those materials can accumulate on the ground. Rain then washes them into the drainage system. The early runoff during a storm, often called the “first flush,” can carry particularly concentrated amounts of pollutants.

Tree boxes are designed to intercept some of that runoff. An opening in the curb directs water into a planted area containing engineered soil. Water can be temporarily stored within the soil, where the system provides an opportunity for filtration and infiltration. Depending on the final configuration, an underdrain and overflow system can also return water to the stormwater system.

At the surface, the tree or vegetation becomes part of the neighborhood landscape. Below it, soil and drainage components allow that same space to play a role in improving the quality of stormwater leaving the neighborhood.

Finding Space in an Established Neighborhood

With the conditions for a viable site established, Clark Dietz turned to geographic information systems (GIS) to narrow the search. The team compiled available data on drainage infrastructure, utilities, topography, tree canopy, impervious surfaces, aerial photography, and other existing conditions to identify areas with the greatest potential for tree boxes and related green infrastructure.

Rather than reviewing the entire 90-acre neighborhood location by location, the team developed a desktop screening process that used those data layers to identify opportunities and filter out known conflicts. Areas with existing trees, mapped utilities, limited space, or other constraints could be screened out, while locations with more available area and access to the stormwater system could be prioritized for a closer look.

The GIS analysis identified more than 130 areas of interest. That gave the team a focused list of potential sites, but it was only the first step. The next step was taking the analysis into the field.

The team evaluated potential locations for drainage opportunity, available planting space, existing trees, utility conflicts, pedestrian access, intersection visibility, proximity to stormwater infrastructure, and other conditions that could affect feasibility. In total, 91 field assessments were completed.

Those visits showed where GIS could guide the search and where on-the-ground conditions changed the picture. In some locations, new trees had been planted since the aerial imagery was collected. Other areas that appeared open on a map were carefully maintained spaces adjoining residents’ homes and were less suitable for a green infrastructure retrofit. Overhead electric and communication lines limited opportunities for taller vegetation, while narrow strips between sidewalks and curbs left little room for a standard tree box.

The combination of desktop analysis and field verification also showed just how constrained the neighborhood was. None of the evaluated locations received the study’s highest feasibility rating. Existing tree canopy, utility congestion, and narrow planting areas meant even the strongest locations involved some level of constraint.

Rather than applying the same solution everywhere, the team considered how each site could respond to different types of green infrastructure. Where overhead utilities or intersection visibility made a tree less practical, low-groundcover bio-cells provided another option for capturing and treating runoff without introducing taller vegetation.

From More Than 130 Possibilities to 15 Priorities

GIS screening and field verification narrowed more than 130 initial areas of interest to 15 priority locations.

Twelve were identified for potential tree boxes and three for low-groundcover bio-cells. Each received a moderate-to-high feasibility rating, the highest achieved within the study area.

Those recommendations gave MSD more than a list of possible locations. They provided a clearer picture of where green infrastructure could function within Cherokee Triangle’s existing streetscape and where further investment in design and coordination would be most worthwhile.

The 15 priority sites now provide a starting point for detailed design, coordination with utilities and nearby property owners, and other planning needed before construction. Because the study is conceptual, additional information gathered during design could still affect the suitability of individual locations, and alternative sites may be considered if conflicts emerge.

Moving Toward Improvements That Last

Finding a location is only part of creating successful green infrastructure. The study also considered planning-level costs, tree box configurations, soil and planting needs, maintenance, and alternative approaches. Those factors influence not only whether an installation can be built, but how well it can continue to function over time.

Vegetation needs enough soil and appropriate growing conditions. Drainage and filtration systems need to continue moving water as intended. Maintenance may include managing litter and mulch, inspecting the installation, and eventually replacing vegetation or other components.

For that reason, the study recommends ongoing performance evaluation and regular monitoring as installations move forward. Lessons from the first projects can help MSD refine future details and apply those lessons to additional green infrastructure efforts.

The feasibility study gives MSD a clear path forward: advance the strongest locations into detailed design, confirm site conditions through utility and property-owner coordination, and continue evaluating performance after installation.

That approach allows each project to do more than treat runoff at a single location. It can also help MSD better understand how green infrastructure performs within established neighborhoods and how similar strategies could be applied in future watershed improvements.

For more information about the Cherokee Triangle Green Infrastructure Feasibility Study or how Clark Dietz can support stormwater and green infrastructure planning, contact Client Advisor Sherry Mulkins; Area Manager Jonathan Rehner, PE; or Project Manager Rob Huckaby, PE.